Roofing materials are quite sturdy. Contractors use only the best materials to make sure roofs stay situated on top of homes and protect everything inside. However, a roof is destined to rot and accumulate damage the longer you have it. If your roof is severely unstable, it’s tempting to just go ahead and replace the entire thing. But experts like A to Z Construction will tell you that it’s better not to jump to this decision so quickly. It might be possible to repair a roof rather than replace it.

Roof Repair vs. Replacement

The decision you make about your damaged roof should depend on several factors, including the severity of the damage, and how much of the surface area needs repair. There are pros and cons to each approach, but these three questions should help you decide the best choice to make:

#1. How Old is Your Roof?

The first question you need to answer is, “what is the age of the roof?” The material also matters. For example, if you have asphalt shingles over 25 years, it’s time to replace them, especially if it’s a large section of the roof that was damaged. Asphalt shingles can last for 30 years, but you don’t want to push your luck. With copper, tile, and slate, your roof can last as long as 50-plus years. Copper sheets can clock 100 years if maintained properly. Some manufacturers also use wood to create roofing sheets. These wood sheets can last for 25 years.

Despite these average lifespan of these materials, the whole roof can get badly damaged due to extreme weather. Hailstorms and harsh winds bring early repairs, depending on your local climate. If you aren’t sure of your roof’s age for various reasons, you should speak to a roofing contractor to tell you how much more battering your roof’s material can take from the elements before deciding to replace.

#2. Do You Plan to Sell Your Home Soon?

Are you still looking to move at some point in the near or distant future? A house with a dilapidated roof can be a hard-sell. Remember the curb appeal; roofs are the first thing your potential buyers see when inspecting the home.  However, if you plan to stay there forever or for a long while, you can consider postponing the replacement if it doesn’t fit your budget. However, keep in mind that potential buyers might be turned off by a roof that needs a lot of work.



#3. What’s Your Budget?

Considering the level of damage, would it be better to replace the roof instead of repairing it? For example, the repair might set you back $3000. But if the replacement would only cost you $4000, then replacing it would give you more bang for your buck.

Roof Repair vs. Replacement - roof replacement

#4. How Large is the Damage?

How extensive is the damage? If you only need to fix one or two shingles, you should probably be discussing repair quotes. However, if over 40% of the roof is destroyed, you should strongly consider getting it replaced.

#5. Are You Under Time Constraints?

Do you have any constraints on your time? An upcoming business trip? Older family members coming over to spend some time with you?  Choosing to replace a roof during this time can be disruptive and noisy. You might also lack the patience to wait for the roofing contractor to do a great job of replacing your roof.

Final Thoughts

If you’re conflicted about getting your roof replaced or not, contact your local roofing contractor. They’ll help you consider the various factors listed above and decide what works for you and your family.